Join free now!

Polyamory vs Swinging 

Frisky Neighbors Saphyre and Carnelian unpack how polyamory and swinging differ, and why both branches of ethical non-monogamy can bring so much joy.

Webinar hosted by Carnelian and Saphyre of FRISKYNEIGHBORS

Join your favorite Frisky Neighbors, Saphyre and Carnelian, in this exclusive SDC webinar to discuss the differences between polyamory and swinging, as well as how both can be enjoyable.

The Tree and Its Many Branches

The hosts framed the conversation around ethical non-monogamy, or ENM, which they described as the umbrella, or "the tree," with many branches growing from it. They emphasized that being in an open relationship does not automatically make someone a swinger or polyamorous.

Carnelian and Saphyre described the "generalized open relationship," in which one or both partners pursue connections outside the marriage independently. In their view, swinging and polyamory are closely intertwined branches of one community. Many people they have met moved from swinging into polyamory, or the other way around.

"If you can have more than one friend, then you can have more than one partner."

Defining Polyamory and Swinging

Carnelian and Saphyre defined polyamory as more than two people in an actual relationship, not simply hooking up, and noted that it can be platonic or not. As one example, two roommates who bring in a third person and all live comfortably together could count as polyamorous. Their rule of thumb was simple: if you find yourself "taking the same person out on dates multiple times, you might as well just turn into a poly relationship." In polyamory, the aim is deep emotional bonds with multiple partners, a network known as a polycule.

Swinging, by contrast, centers on a core couple who stay together and go out to "play," forming connections and friendships with certain groups without building full dating relationships. The hosts shared that swinging focuses on recreational sex and partner swapping while the primary couple remains emotionally exclusive. Swinging tends to be couples-oriented and often happens at clubs or events, while polyamory is more individualized, with each person potentially holding multiple romantic relationships.

In terms of intimacy, swinging is physical while polyamory is both emotional and physical. In terms of goals, swinging aims for sexual variety and fun ("I like the fun part"), while polyamory aims for multiple loving relationships. And in terms of communication, polyamory requires more complex, ongoing emotional conversations, including feelings about metamours, meaning a partner's partner.

How the Hosts Found Their Fit

Interestingly, Saphyre and Carnelian set out wanting polyamory. As they considered how they'd know whether a third or fourth person was the right fit, they agreed to date people together. That path led them to swinging. It suited them better, and today their social circle is mostly swinger couples. They've seen poly dynamics and throuples in the community and follow poly groups online, though they haven't met many fully polyamorous people in person.

When it comes to labels, Saphyre and Carnelian admit they don't fit neatly into either category. Their best description is "a closed open relationship that swings." They swing because it's easiest right now and because they love doing everything together. Yet they remain open to welcoming a third or a couple and becoming poly. 

Their new tagline is "vibe hunters." Whether a connection lasts one day or ten years doesn't matter, as long as the vibe is there. When it isn't, they back off quickly, especially when drama appears. As one of them puts it, "I'm allergic to that."

When Swinging Turns Into Something Deeper

An audience member asked what happens when swinging partners develop deeper feelings. If the deeper connection is welcome, "by all means jump on it." If not, sit down and talk with the other couple. Possible dynamics include four people where only three are romantically involved, or a situation where only the wives share a romantic relationship. A regular play partner could even become a poly partner, and "next thing you know you guys are skiing in Colorado."

A listener wondered what to do if sexual chemistry with a new partner seems better than with their own. Saphyre and Carnelian pointed to new relationship energy, or NRE. New feels easier and smoother because you have not lived with that person or learned their habits. They compared it to a new friendship "bromance" that flames out after a few months. 

If couples in a foursome discover they click better swapped, the hosts see nothing wrong with that. They can talk it through or "do a little flip or switch," because the dynamic is theirs to decide.

Facing Jealousy and FOMO

"Jealousy exists. Don't run from it." It appears in both swinging and polyamory and can surface suddenly after a new experience. Saphyre and Carnelian's approach is to identify the underlying cause first, then bring it to partners and ask, "What can we all do and bring to the table to help alleviate some of this?"

A listener comment offered a helpful reframe: often jealousy is "not that you don't want the other to have it, but you long for it yourself." The hosts connected this to FOMO, which can range from missing out on a car ride or a Disneyland trip to a partner getting a boyfriend or girlfriend first.

Taking It Slow and Staying Safe

Adding people to a relationship means relearning habits and communication styles across three or four people instead of one. That's a key reason Saphyre and Carnelian are taking their time with polyamory. Dating as a group feels like dating again, only harder, because everyone's wants and limits matter. Swinging partners, by comparison, are "just friends" who "can go home" to their own house. They still look out for one another, like bringing over soup when someone's sick.

Saphyre and Carnelian vet new partners slowly with a "90 days" rule. People's true behavior tends to show around three months in, once they get comfortable. Some prospects turned out to be "just a decent friend." They're "not going to force it" and are "not hunting." Their long-term hope is that someone moves in and becomes part of their household.

They also shared a term they recently discovered. "Cowboying" or "cowgirling" describes a person, usually monogamous, who joins a poly dynamic intending to "cut them off from the herd." It often involves manipulation or ultimatums. Saphyre and Carnelian call it "predatory." Early on, one of them worried about this happening. The other felt secure but worried about losing time together.

Preferences, Styles, and Everyday Life

Saphyre and Carnelian prefer adding a couple instead of a single person. That way each of them has a partner and no one is left out. She prefers two men with her, and he prefers two women with him, though they think women "tend to be easier" as a starting point. Swinging styles vary widely, from one-night play to repeat encounters with a compatible couple. Some swinger couples even become close friends without any romantic bond, a middle ground that may not have a name yet.

At home, Saphyre and Carnelian keep "vanilla" gatherings separate from lifestyle ones. Their home features pineapple decor, one of the well-known swinger symbols, and they joke that one pineapple "could be turned upside down pretty quickly." Some vanilla friends know about their lifestyle. A few aren't interested, while others have lots of questions, which Saphyre and Carnelian enjoy answering. Since their recent move, they're more guarded because they don't know people well yet.

Household dynamics can change a relationship and call for careful conversation. Saphyre and Carnelian recommend regular "round table" check-ins even when nothing is wrong. Try a simple prompt like "Hey, do we wanna talk about X, Y, Z?" A talking torch helps everyone get a turn. After all, silence "is gonna get boring real quick."

Kink, BDSM, and the Birth of "Spaghetti"

Saphyre and Carnelian describe kink and BDSM as separate categories that "bleed into" ethical non-monogamy. Some swingers dabble in BDSM, while others are poly because of it. Role-play is one of the most popular kinks. Because lifestyle communication runs so high, kink feels far less "hush hush" than in vanilla circles.

Saphyre and Carnelian call themselves BDSM "dabblers." "We know enough about BDSM to say with utter confidence, we know nothing." Their advice is to "always ask questions." For her, trust comes first, especially when someone is being tied up.

Asked whether she's bi, she coined a new word, "spaghetti." She's "straight until you're basically effectively turned on." They see "erotic orientation," meaning attraction based on arousal in the moment, as the "scientific name" for spaghetti. Their playful tagline is "Turn me on and let's go."

Do Your Research and Join the Neighborhood

For anyone unsure where they fit, the hosts encourage researching definitions, websites, and experts. There are different types of swingers and different types of poly, and if someone lands in a blend, that blend is exactly where they belong.

Carnelian and Saphyre aim to share the basics and most common terms as a starting point so listeners are "not led astray," and they commit to citing their sources: "I'm not pulling this out of a dictionary." Since standard dictionaries do not come close to covering lifestyle vocabulary, they have branched out to sources like Urban Dictionary and are even floating a swinger's edition dictionary this year, tentatively called "the pineapple lover's dictionary."

They acknowledged that sexual orientation types, which strongly shape swinger dynamics, deserve their own session, joking that covering it all would take "a month of webinars."


Event Flyer

Original webinar was live-streamed on SDC.com Monday, January 26th, 2026

 

0 Likes
0 Comments
LIKE
COMMENT
0